If you’re currently in the market for a sporty, luxurious vehicle, then you’ve surely been debating the Maserati Ghibli vs. Jaguar XJ. From an outsider’s perspective, this is a reasonable comparison, as the two vehicles seemingly provide everything a driver could possibly want from a pricey ride: performance, luxury, and technology. However, when you really begin to dig into the specifics of the vehicle, you’ll find that one vehicle is vastly superior, mostly because of its dependability and reliability.
Fortunately, you don’t have to take my word for it. I’ve scoured the internet for reviews on the two models. Unsurprisingly, it wasn’t particularly hard to find that consumers preferred Maserati’s luxurious vehicle over Jaguar’s. If you’re in the market for a similar ride, see why the Ghibli is the superior option…
First, let’s dive into the Jaguar reviews, with the following testimonials coming via ConsumerAffairs.com. We’ll review the main sentiments after you see what these current owners had to say about their ride:
Brad from Orlando: “BOUGHT NEW 2016 XJL $89,000 window sticker, it has been in their Merritt Island, FL Jaguar shop over 6 times for problems, radio issues, dash issues, and too many more to list! Jaguar of North America really doesn’t give a damn about their customers, and their dealer doesn’t carry many parts, so be prepared to leave your car for a few days just to get it back “not fixed”. Have complained 2 times about 1 tire that keeps losing air every 3 to 5 days, have fun filling up your 1 tire that often! The dealership didn’t have a tire sensor in stock and I guess they want me to return 3 times for the same problem? NOT GOING TO HAPPEN! Don’t waste your hard earned $$ on a JAGUAR!”
Bill from Windermere: “New $90,000 plus Jaguar XJL. The car has been in the shop Four times for over a total of 20 days. All kind of electrical problems, most prevalent is with Bluetooth disconnecting or instrument panel blanking out completely. Jaguar has no idea how to fix the issues and refuses to replace the computers. They have asked us to wait for a major software update that in July. This is our fifth Jaguar XJ and by far the worse electronics of any of the over 25 cars I have owned.”
Danny from Vancouver: “BRAND NEW 2016 Jaguar XJL. After reading all the review, now I know I’m not alone in the dark. Been back in the service shop for 4 times, in just 2 mo. First, with the Bluetooth/audio cutting on & off, they upgraded the software system. The problem still remained. Second, the dashboard will just turn off itself to completely black. Almost got into an accident while driving on the highway at night. I don’t have time to type all the problem, the more I type the more pissed I am. Is 2107 already, JAGUAR put your act together.”
Clearly, the main takeaway here is that the brand shouldn’t be trusted mechanically. It isn’t a coincidence that several XJ owners complained of constant issues with their vehicle, whether it’s a software concern, wheel, and tire problem, or general issues with the entire system. You’re already going to be dishing out a pretty penny on your new vehicle, so you surely won’t want to be spending extra cash thanks to constant trips to the mechanic. While the aesthetics of the Jaguar XJL certainly makes it appealing, there’s no denying that this nameplate should be avoided if you don’t want to deal with an inevitable headache.
Fortunately, as you’re about to learn, there’s a fine alternative for those seeking a sporty, luxurious vehicle. While the Jaguar XJ didn’t receive the most glowing reviews, consumers were much happier with the Maserati Ghibli. Using several cars.com reviews, we’ve been able to fully confirm that sentiment:
Joe from McHenry: “Ok, I own Ghibli for two months now and this is the best car owned as of yet! I had X5 previously and cannot even compare to this daredevil! This is one amazing car that makes you feel like you’re on to of the world when you behind the wheel. I love it and would never come back to German cars again. Love it and love it again….”
Mia from St. Petersburg: “After one week of ownership I am as thrilled as I was when waiting for the car to be delivered. It is one of the most fun cars I have ever driven, and I have owned a Corvette, several Cadillacs, Lexus Ls460 and Jaguar XJL, so I have experience across a range of vehicles. My Ghibli SQ4 has the luxury and driver packages plus 20-inch wheels. It’s the bronze metallic with a light leather interior. Simply beautiful outside and in. The 404 HP engine is spectacular with very quick response. I hope my opinion remains as high several years down the road. I graded the reliability only to be able to complete this survey because it’s too early to report, but through the first several hundred miles I couldn’t be happier.”
Ken from Inglewood: “IF YOUR LOOKING TO STAND OUT FROM THE CROWD OF MERCEDES AND BMW WITH A SUPER FAST SUPERCAR, THIS IS IT. THIS CAR TURNS HEADS EVERYWHERE YOU GO. WHAT IS THIS CAR? IS IT AS FAST AS IT LOOKS YESYES YES YOU LIKE ME WILL BE THE ENVY OF YOUR FRIENDS DRIVING A SUPERCAR MASERATI IS THE WAY TO GO.”
We’re not entirely sure why that final consumer was shouting, but it’s pretty evident that car owners seem to be significantly happier with the Maserati Ghibli as opposed to the Jaguar XJ. Mechanical issues aren’t even mentioned, as the brand typically produces some of the most dependable vehicles on the road.
Rather, consumers focused on the vehicle’s incredible performance capabilities, and they were obviously enamored with the exterior and interior aesthetics. Clearly, you don’t have to take our word for it; when it comes to the Maserati Ghibli vs Jaguar XJ, it’s clear that the latter offering is the superior target.